As if being a complete improv nerd isn’t enough of an indictment on my “cool guy” credentials, I am also a fairly experienced magician. When I was in college, my wife lived in VA and I lived in Charleston. Practicing magic gave me something to do when I was in the house alone instead of being afraid that my neighbor’s police dog would break in to kill me (not a joke, I believed it.) While there were a number of tools that I was capable of using in a magic trick, cards were my absolute favorite.
All of my friends in my electrical engineering program would do our studying in the Barnes & Noble close to my home. For those of you who don’t know, Barnes & Noble was a magical place where one could purchase a book from human beings and have a cup of coffee. This was long before the experience was usurped by the safety of cyberspace, where you don’t have to worry about being chloroformed near the books on baby names.
One night we were studying for a tough test in Antennas and Propagation. It was very difficult to focus, as you would expect from anything involving differential equations. In an attempt to distract myself, I began throwing cards at a bookshelf just outside of the coffee shop. I am not good enough to cut a banana in half, but I can put a bit of pepper on the queen of spades in a pinch. I kept throwing cards for a few minutes, and then something strange happened. The ace of hearts hooked upwards and lodged itself in the cork ceiling of the bookstore, about 25 feet above the display for Freakonomics. The Navy taught me to never leave a man behind, but that ace became a prisoner of the war on boredom.

A week later, I went to the bookstore hoping to find a decent book on CD, maybe one read by James Earl Jones. On the way in I saw a woman looking at the dust jacket for Freakonomics, deciding whether to buy it or not. I approached her, hoping to perform a trick for her. Luckily, one way to not seem intimidating as a lone black guy is to have a deck of Bicycle cards in your hand. She said yes.

I began a common magic routine where she selected a card, by chance the Ace of Hearts, and placed it in the center of the deck. Once the card is in the center, the spectator snaps her fingers and the card comes back to the top of the deck. I did this once, just to cement her expectations. I placed the card in the deck a second time and I asked her to snap. This time, however, I snapped with her. When I turned over the top card, it wasn’t hers.
“Did I not snap hard enough?” she asked.
“I think we snapped too hard.” I said, pointing to the ceiling. She let out a scream that was a wonderful mixture of glee and fear. She then thanked me and grabbed a copy of the book to buy. “After seeing that, I know I was meant to be standing here.”

In my mind, improvisation has many similarities to other things that I love. In the case of magic, it is a very easy connection to explain. When improv is executed properly, it seems like a magic trick. The average person watching will be amazed at your ability to be so nimble of thought, recall so much information, and be on the same page as your fellow players. At its best, the members of the audience will say, “You must have made some of that up beforehand, right?” This is because the notion that people could collectively create a vivid tapestry of ideas without forethought simultaneously reeks of trickery and teems with majesty.
“Life is filled with surprise and wonder and astonishment for those whose hearts and minds are open to receive them” Dr. Eugene Burger (Magician and Philosopher)
The magical quality of improv can be considered in one of a few ways: a magician performing for family, a magician performing for a stranger, and a magician performing for another magician.
When performing for family, the audience refuses to see your failure, almost to a fault. If I had performed that card trick for my mother, I could have walked away with a false sense of my effectiveness as a performer. She could have seen every detail of how the card rose to the top of the deck and spotted the card in the ceiling on her way in the store. She still would have given a response commensurate with what I experienced in the store. Her excitement lies in the fact that she is getting to see me perform.
For those of us that perform improv exclusively for friends and family, we get to see a similar phenomenon. We could have what we consider the worst show of our lives. Onstage denials that would make Bill Clinton wag his finger in shame. No real establishment of relationships, dropped games, and a general inability to listen may have plagued the players on a given night. Your family will still greet you after the show and tell you “Wow, you were great up there. It’s amazing that you guys can do that.” They are telling the truth, so far as they see it.

When performing for strangers, the audience enters the situation with an element of skepticism that is usually outweighed by their desire to enjoy the experience. They may not recognize why something wasn’t done correctly, but they are more apt to perceive it than family. Most won’t come up to you and overtly tell you, “You made me choke on my own bile!” However, they may or may not come up to you after the show to tell you how much of a hoot you were… you have to earn it.
Lastly, there is the idea of performing for other magicians. There are in excess of 25 ways to place a card in the center of a deck and make it “magically” rise to the top. If I were performing the described trick for another magician, I would have felt compelled to do it in the most difficult and knuckle-shattering manner possible. The magician would have known immediately that I was going into an “Ambitious Card” routine, and began judging me on technical proficiency. He has no expectation of enjoying the routine, because he is watching as an expert. The challenge associated with this is that you feel compelled to prove how much of an expert you are.

Imagine how this affects teams that play rooms filled with improvisers. The fact of the matter is that the audience is not there to laugh, in this case. They are there fulfilling the laboratory requirement for their own improv education. This can lead players to overemphasize different aspects of their scene work to show their abilities. I have never seen better object work than when I was sitting in one of these shows, but sometimes that is all the set amounted to… a workshop in improv skills. To be fair, I have also seen some of the most magical onstage work in these same rooms. Keep in mind, David Blaine can still have his mind blown by the right magician, especially when the performer goes out on a limb and does something unexpected.
“Confusion isn’t magic”- Dai Vernon (the Del Close of Card Magic) 
Why do I tell you all of this? I do love talking about magic, but that wasn’t my overall point. I think that it can be helpful to know what sort of circumstance you happen to be in. The reason this occurred to me was because of a conversation I had with my wife before she saw her first show at iO. Years ago she had seen an iO troupe at the Charleston Comedy Festival. They played the way they would in front of a room full of improvisers to a room full of strangers. They were spectacular scene painters, but the audience didn’t give two shits about that. They had come to see improv comedy, not an exhibition of the player’s skills. I, later, had to drag her kicking and screaming to see TJ & Dave, because she was convinced that all improvisers in Chicago were taught to play that way. And I assure you she wasn’t the only person that got that impression. If they had considered what audience they were playing for, it may have been a much more successful experience for everyone involved.
It isn’t my intent to say which way is better. All three of the situations above are legitimate ways to express our art and connect with an audience. In reality, everything that I have said is more of a comment on my own play than anyone else’s. I would like for you to consider the following: When we take the stage, magic is created. Some of the best improvisation occurs when you have an outcome that you can’t even explain to yourself. When it seems magical to you, you know you have succeeded. Knowing what level of sorcery we aim to present will ensure that we are mystifying the public in a way befitting their expectations.





































A Navy Captain (O-6) walks up in an effort to catch the same shuttle. The Commander’s dick instantly shrinks three inches. He focuses on the Captain’s story about getting a flat tire on the way to church. He laughs at the Captain’s joke about it being a sign that he should have stayed home to watch the Cowboys game. Most degradingly, he allows the Captain to mispronounce his name. His name isn’t difficult to pronounce; it’s Wesley.



